Free Shipping On Orders Over $75

Sell on Farmart. Register Now

For Lenten, is it fish fries or frys? We went to the top to get an answer | Where NOLA Eats |

Lent is here.

So is the salvation of many a harried Catholic couple with three or four mouths to feed on a seafood-only Friday night: the parish fish fry.

The fish fry has become a savory staple of parish fellowship. All in good fun, and in the advancement of culinary civilization, many parishes in the Archdiocese of New Orleans have embarked on a seafood arms race that would require drones with infrared cameras to monitor properly.

What used to be fairly simple fare — one piece of fried catfish, a couple of scoops of potato salad and a dinner roll — has evolved into delights more suited for silver-platter covers than for Styrofoam. Think Brigsten’s and Galatoire’s, not the Men’s Club in the school cafeteria.

Seeking repeat business and word-of-mouth promotion, some parishes vary their menus each Friday of Lent, providing alternating options such as shrimp and okra, blackened catfish, shrimp and grits, shrimp pasta Alfredo, crab and corn bisque, and, for the healthy eater, even grilled redfish.

The fish fry also brings to mind an esoteric grammar lesson — really, a pitched battle where semicolons, ampersands and the Oxford comma are flung into the sky like arrows — regarding the proper usage of the plural of fish “fry.”

Inquiring minds need to know: Should the headline of their calendar-of-events listings be fish “fries” or fish “frys”?

There are rules to be followed, even when both possible answers look wrong.

First, let’s dispense with what we know the plural of fish fry is not. Anyone who uses fish “fry’s” — where the apostrophe somehow tricks the brain into believing a possessive is a plural — is hereby required to repeat third grade with Sister Mary de Lourdes, for whom the improper use of an apostrophe would bring on a case of apoplexy.

Normally, in tough cases of grammar usage, editors rely on The Associated Press stylebook, which, of course, is conspiratorially silent on the plural of fish fry.

Often, it’s helpful to Google the two competing versions — in this case, “Is it fish fries or fish frys?” — and then see what pops up. When the replies come up 50-50, that’s about as helpful and accurate as flipping a coin.

That’s not a good answer.

Enter Alex Martin, writing chief of The Wall Street Journal, a Holy Cross High School graduate who worked for The Times-Picayune in the 1980s and then for New York Newsday on Long Island for 16 years.

Martin attended Sts. Peter and Paul Elementary School on Burgundy Street, and his dad used to work at the family restaurant — Martin’s Po-Boys — on St. Claude Avenue.

“We ate fish a lot on Fridays, but there was all manner of stuff — fried fish, fish sticks and French fry po-boys,” Martin said. “We would eat the French fry po-boys without the stuff that makes them great — the roast beef gravy.”

Martin knows po-boys. He also knows poor grammar. Realizing the culinary history of New Orleans rested on the answer to the plural of fish fry, he embarked on a serious investigation.

Every Thursday we give you the scoop on NOLA dining. Sign up today.

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Would you like to receive notifications on latest updates? No Yes

We would love to hear from you!

Please record your message.

Record, Listen, Send

Allow access to your microphone

Click "Allow" in the permission dialog. It usually appears under the address bar in the upper left side of the window. We respect your privacy.

Microphone access error

It seems your microphone is disabled in the browser settings. Please go to your browser settings and enable access to your microphone.

Speak now


Canvas not available.

Reset recording

Are you sure you want to start a new recording? Your current recording will be deleted.

Oops, something went wrong

Error occurred during uploading your audio. Please click the Retry button to try again.

Send your recording

Thank you

    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop
      Apply Coupon
      Available Coupons
      2d6zkrps6x Get 10% off
      ae9cb5tuhs Get 10% off
      gdhvhilwts Get 10% off
      mixjwcpaty Get 10% off
      pkpjjfrf4r Get 10% off
      vnj9z71pds Get 10% off
      x8flq1kvdo Get 10% off
      Unavailable Coupons
      09yrbm Get 10% off
      59dj9l Get 10% off
      917hz7 Get 10% off
      dlim3v Get 10% off
      dwztn4 Get 10% off
      ehvlsv Get 10% off
      hb3xmy Get 10% off
      kqmxxi Get 10% off
      lui02l Get 10% off
      r6w13j Get 10% off
      smzfxm Get 10% off
      ufp2sy Get 10% off
      welcome25 Get 25% off Welcome to the all new 3.0
      Shopping Cart 0

      No products in the cart.

      WANT 10% OFF?
      Subscribe now to get free discount coupon code. Don't miss out!
        I agree with the term and condition